Did you know...
4 minutes of positive news a day decreases anxiety & increases optimism!

Get unlimited access and a personalized positive news feed sent right to your inbox with a...

30 Day Trial

(no credit card required)


Sign Up!

Did you know...
4 minutes of positive news a day decreases anxiety and increases optimism!

Get unlimited access and a personalized positive news feed sent right to your inbox with a...

30 Day Trial

(no credit card required)


Sign Up!
View Collection
Image: Two staircases headed in opposite directions, one beige and one teal. Representing the way there can be two sides to one story.

Middle Version: How to Interpret Two Sides of One Story

This article by Robert Glazer originally appeared on Friday Forward.

Many years ago, I received a courtesy call from someone in our industry who I had never met before. He was letting me know about an interaction he’d had with a member of my team at an industry event that was not very favorable.

While the caller did not want to get the person in trouble, he shared that our team member was aggressively selling to him at a social event connected to the conference and also appeared intoxicated. He wanted to reach out because he did not feel that behavior represented what he knew about our brand.

As you can imagine, I was furious when I heard this story. However, as I often do in emotional situations, I slept on it for 24 hours. The next day I called the employee to discuss what had happened, expecting them to acknowledge the situation and apologize profusely for their behavior. But the employee was very surprised by my call; they insisted that they had a very positive interaction with the person who had called me, and that they were not even drinking at the event.

Image: Two staircases headed in opposite directions, one beige and one teal. Representing the way there can be two sides to one story.
Source: Unsplash

I was shocked and confused, but I probably should not have been. In all facets of life, this dynamic plays out: two people will often tell very different stories about the same event, for any number of reasons.

As I worked to manage the situation with this employee, I learned two powerful leadership lessons. I’ve carried these learnings to this day, especially when reconciling conflicting stories between two people.

The first lesson is that people tend to cast themselves in the best light when they share a story, often minimizing any culpability of their own and embellishing the actions of the other person. Part of this is just good old fashioned cognitive dissonance; we often struggle to accept that we’ve done something wrong or bad when we think of ourselves as good people.

I have also seen this lesson play out clearly in the very rare cases over the past fifteen years where an employee acted dishonestly or with extremely poor judgment and faced appropriate consequences. The version of the story they went on to tell their peers was extremely disconnected from the objective facts and significantly downplayed their own actions.

The second lesson is that as leaders, friends and parents, we often fall victim to the primacy effect. The primacy effect is a psychological principle, and a form of cognitive bias, that causes us to better remember the first piece of information we receive about a situation.

Not only do we remember the first side of a story better, but our brains use that one-sided perspective to dictate our opinions, emotions and actions. This often makes it difficult to hear the other side of the story objectively—we struggle to dismiss our initial impression, especially if we have to dismiss our prior pre-conceptions in order to see the truth in the second version of the story.

To combat the primacy effect, we need to remember that, in most cases, the truth lies somewhere in the middle. When we hear two people share contradictory versions of the same story, it’s important to recall that it’s rare for someone to objectively recount their role in a given situation; when a person is a main character in a story, it’s hard for them to also be an objectively reliable narrator.

The next time you hear a story that may have a different perspective, do your best to reserve judgment or action until you have heard the other side of the story, or gathered the relevant facts from objective observers. This is a case where being first and being right/accurate are not one and the same.

  • Bob Glazer

Don’t miss out on a single article!

Enjoy unlimited access to over 500 articles & podcast that give you a positive perspective on the state of the world and show you practical ways you can help.

Sign up now!
Published: January 13, 2023

Robert Glazer

Content Partner

Robert Glazer is the founder and CEO of Acceleration Partners, the author of the inspirational newsletter Friday Forward, and the #1 Wall Street Journal, USA Today and international bestselling author of four books: Elevate, Friday Forward, How To Thrive In The Virtual Workplace and Performance Partnerships.  He is a sought-after speaker by companies and organizations around the world and is the host of The Elevate Podcast.

Join for as little as $3 per month

As a Member, you get instant access to unlimited good news, fresh ideas, and positive perspectives. Don't miss out on full access to articles, podcasts, videos, and curated playlists of our content, as well as our weekly newsletter, and access to our mobile app!

Become a Member

Follow Us

Cut through today’s negative noise.

There is a wave of goodness and progress well underway, all around the world.